When you order from The Pie Lady On 5 you can be assured your pies are made 100% from scratch. I make your pies one at a time using fresh ingredients when in season and rolling each and every pie crust by hand with my trusty rolling pin.

PIE, IT’S All I DO!

Baking With the Pie Lady on 5
Bake right along with me!

Enjoy 22 of my favorite pie recipes, with everything you need to know to produce drool-worthy pies in your own kitchen.

Written to bring out the inner Pie Lady in everyone, I’m sharing all of my tips and tricks for novices and pie-pros alike that I’ve learned from a lifetime of pie making – and pie eating.

Enjoy!

Order Book
Reduced Hours and Menu

Jan-Mar
2nd and 4th Friday, pick-up 3-6 pm
Prefer orders be placed at least 48 hours in advance

Pies: Sugar Cream, Chocolate Sugar Cream, Blueberry Cream, Blueberry Crumb, Cherry Crumb, Apple Crumb.
Sugar Cream Pie Mixes
Baking With The Pie Lady on 5 Cookbook
Gift Certificates

Menu (order form at the bottom of the page)

$14 Pies

APPLE (SEASONAL)
CHERRY
CHERRY CRUMB
CHOCOLATE PECAN
CHOCOLATE SUGAR CREAM
COCONUT SUGAR CREAM
DUTCH APPLE (SEASONAL)
PECAN
PEACH
PEACH CRUMB
RUSTIC APPLE (SEASONAL)

$12 Pies

BLUEBERRY
BLUEBERRY CREAM
BLUEBERRY CRUMB
CARLENE’S SUGAR CREAM
CARLENE’S SUGAR CREAM W/ PEACHES
PUMPKIN
RHUBARB (SEASONAL)
RHUBARB CREAM (SEASONAL)
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE FILLING MIX – $9
SUGAR CREAM PIE FILLING MIX – $9

Pies make a wonderful addition to your wedding

They go with any theme, rustic, casual or elegant. It’s all in the presentation. Let The Pie Lady On 5 help make your special day the best it can be with the best pies around.

Please message me for more information about dates, and deposits.

LIFE WITHOUT PIE IS LIKE NO LIFE AT ALL.

Order – Pre order for pickup at my roadside stand

  • If you are placing an order, please include the item, quantity, and desired pick-up date. If you plan on freezing any of the pies, please let me know that as well. Most orders require two days notice but give me a call if you need it sooner. Once your order is placed, I will contact you within 24 hours to confirm your order. If I haven't confirmed in 24 hours, please call me.

    Pick Up Policy
    If you are unable to pick up your pie at the appointed time please call 260-224-7992. If you are a no call, no show, I am unable to hold your pie for later pick up. My goal is to provide my customers with the freshest pie possible.
    Forms of Payment
    Cash or Check made payable to Carlene Staller. Exact change is always appreciated.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.