When you order from The Pie Lady On 5 you can be assured your pies are made 100% from scratch. I make your pies one at a time using fresh ingredients when in season and rolling each and every pie crust by hand with my trusty rolling pin.

When you order from The Pie Lady On 5 you know your pie is made fresh the day you pick it up. I pride myself on making the BEST PIES I can for my valued customers.

PIE, IT’S All I DO!


Thanksgiving 2020

Thanksgiving orders will be different this year in an attempt to fill all the orders for my customers. I hate to turn anyone away. This will also make it possible for me to offer a few more varieties. The following pies can be ordered and picked up for freezing any time from Oct 10th – Nov 14th: Cherry Crumb, Blueberry Crumb, Pecan and Carlene’s Sugar Cream Pie. I have frozen all of these and, with some experimentation from Natalie at Rolling Pin Bakehouse, the sugar cream pie is now freezable too. After Nov 14th, these cannot be ordered for Thanksgiving.

I will offer the following for pick up on Wed. the 25th of Nov. for Thanksgiving: Pumpkin and Dutch Apple. I will not fill any orders for pies after Nov 18th, as I will be doing as much prep as possible. Please plan accordingly for your family Thanksgivings.

I appreciate all my wonderful customers and want to fill as many of your orders as possible, so hopefully this will work into your plans. This will be much less stressful for me and will allow me to stretch my baking times out instead of doing it all on one day. As I get older, it just gets a little harder.

Thanks so much.

I will schedule pick ups at least 30 minutes apart and I will ask you to have the exact change and put it in an envelope with your name on it. To limit contact with customers I will have your pie on the pie cart and then you can put your money in the money box inside the cart. Hopefully things will get back to normal soon and I will be able to offer more pies.

Menu (order form at the bottom of the page)

$14 Pies

APPLE (SEASONAL)
CHERRY
CHERRY CRUMB
CHOCOLATE PECAN
DUTCH APPLE (SEASONAL)
PECAN
PEACH
PEACH CRUMB
RUSTIC APPLE (SEASONAL)

$14 Sugar Free Pies

APPLE
BLUEBERRY
BLUEBERRY CRUMB
DUTCH APPLE
PEACH
PEACH CRUMB
RHUBARB (SEASONAL)

$12 Pies

BLUEBERRY
BLUEBERRY CREAM
BLUEBERRY CRUMB
CARLENE’S SUGAR CREAM
CARLENE’S SUGAR CREAM W/ PEACHES
APPLE DUMPLINGS (SEASONAL) – 4 FOR $14
CHOCOLATE SUGAR CREAM
COCONUT SUGAR CREAM
PUMPKIN
RHUBARB (SEASONAL)
RHUBARB CREAM (SEASONAL)

Pies make a wonderful addition to your wedding

They go with any theme, rustic, casual or elegant. It’s all in the presentation. Let The Pie Lady On 5 help make your special day the best it can be with the best pies around.

Please message me for more information about dates, and deposits.

LIFE WITHOUT PIE IS LIKE NO LIFE AT ALL.

Order – Pre order for pickup at my roadside stand

    Name (required)


    Email (required)


    Phone (required)


    Your Message

    If you are placing an order, please include the item, quantity, and desired pick-up date. If you plan on freezing any of the pies, please let me know that as well. Most orders require two days notice but give me a call if you need it sooner. Once your order is placed, I will contact you within 24 hours to confirm your order.

    Pick Up Policy
    If you are unable to pick up your pie at the appointed time please call 260-224-7992. If you are a no call, no show, I am unable to hold your pie for later pick up. My goal is to provide my customers with the freshest pie possible.
    Forms of Payment
    Cash or Check made payable to Carlene Staller